StackToSale
I Burnt $800 on PMax So You Don’t Have To

I Burnt $800 on PMax So You Don’t Have To

5/28/2025

I let Google cook.
Spoiler: They burned the kitchen down.

The Setup

Google whispered:

“Trust the AI.”
I whispered back:
“Sure.”
3 days later:

What Went Wrong

PMax with no signals = Google guessing your customer is… everyone.
So they showed my ads to:

Basically, the cheapest CPMs on Earth with zero buying intent.

What I Learned (So You Don’t Have To)

Never launch PMax blind. Give it some direction (audiences, asset groups, conversion history).

Check placements. You’ll cry.

Start with manual or search before PMax. Let Google learn from your data, not your wallet.

PMax is a multiplier, not a miracle. If your funnel sucks, it’ll suck faster.

TL;DR

I paid $800 to teach Google who my customers aren’t.
Next time, I’ll send them a memo instead.